Homey Community Forum

How to migrate to a Homey Pro?

I have arround 25 apps and it is slow… HUE app alone is using 60mb of RAM. Each app takes at ninimum 10mb.

If I count all apps I get to 475mb of RAM + 145mb for HOMEY, which is more than 512… I guess it pages the rest. This is a day after homey reset.

So @Rocodamelsheki please advise how can I lower the memory usage…

And what is ur definition of slow?

Not sure what you really mean then. Do you mean it is slow in actual behaviour or do you mean it is slow because you think it uses too much memory?
It too have an early model with 20 apps, 75 flows, 50 z-wave and 25 Zigbee devices and it is functioning fine.

In general I know how fast homey was in the begining, but it was different version of software and firmware and I had less apps and devices, so I don’t know what is the reason.

I have about 130 devices. 30 z-wave, 25 zigbee, 50 devices via HUE bridge and arround 25 other devices(RF, WiFi, …). And about 70 flows…

For me slow mens:
It is not as fast in direct actions as ti used to be(devices on/off, settings, …).
I get timeouts or very long waiting when setting the parameters or trying to control a device.
When editing the flows in app or web, just not fast enough to get any real logic done(click on card and it loads for 5-10 seconds for example).
Flow that lowers/lifts the blinds sometimes does one blind at the time instead of all the blinds at once as it normaly does(reboot solves this).

Sometimes it is so slow I can barely log on to the app…maybe I try 10 times and it loads. Last time I tried to generate support ID for support and it would timeout generating the ID for 5 or 10 times.

The reboot itself takes about 10+ minutes to load every app and device. After a reboot in general everything works OK with the speeds I can live with. But in a day or two I notice the slow factor again.

Homey works somehow but I believe that some optimization would speed thing up, but don’t have any Idea how to do the optimizations, it is just to much stuff.

I have daily reboot at 2AM so I don’t have errors and stuff, but the speed is not perfect even after reboot.

1 Like

Same here. Going to upgrade to Homey Pro with antenna mods. About 200 devices (of which there are 130 hue lights through three Philips hubs, rest are zwave), pro rato amount of flows. Slow for me means sometimes response after one minuut, frequently no response from flow when zwave click on e.g. Fibaro Switch. Going to migrate manually, but I would REALLY have wished an automatic migration.

The 130 Hue lights shouldn’t be a problem as they are hosted by their own gateways and not directly by Homey.

So to me it sounds as a possible Z-wave mesh problem. I had the same with my Homey, even when i put Coolcam plugs in every room.
It improved significantly after the antenna mod and a re-positioning of my Homey.
So why don’t you try to do the mod before upgrading to see if that helps?

It seems 130 hues does slow down Homey, maybe lots of iterations somewhere in their code for many devices. I don’t know. I’m betting on multiple horses, cause of the WAF which is reaching critical levels: “Homey out, or I’m out!”, cause of lights not responding. I see the UI/responsiveness of Homey is also quite slow many times, and sporadically no response at all. So I’m moving to antenna mod and a faster Homey with more memory. Thx for thinking along!

And you take a look at the developer page regularly to see what the mesh does? Or on the insights page to see what the memory usage does over time?
This could help to see what happens and maybe why.

Btw, i don’t understand why 130 hue lights should slow down Homey significantly if they are really connected to the hue hubs. Afaik Homey sends the command to the hue hub(s) and they steer the light. And the hue hub does that faster and better then Homey himself so i understood by reading different topics about it.
Correct me if i’m wrong.

Don’t know why it is just slow im bought homey just because I got sick of fiddling with opensource home automation software…

But reboot seems to help. After a while memory increases for HUE app, probably becouse of all the devices. Homey pools hue bridge costatnly with the light status and in the end I guess uses lots of memory or the app just has memory leeaks…
Plus there are other apps like MQTT for me that is quite demanding on memory.

I also tought about adding additional normal homey but I don’t believe there is a way for two homey’s to talk to eachother out of the box. Maybe via MQTT. Would get load balanced apps on two homeys and 2x IR in different rooms. but again it is a lot of work and increase in complexity.

Homey Pro should be a solution I believe. Will see when we try :). I just wont buy it and start migrating before there is an official way. If athom wont do this backup/restore, then I will live with old homey and reboot it every so often I guess. 400€ less for them. I kind of learned to live with the constant homey issues. Lights still works even if homey dies as HUE bridge works perfect.

I’m probably not alone, just many people don’t bother complaining as they see other people allready bugging the crowd :slight_smile:

There were/are several reports of memory leak (sometimes especially from the Hue app) that slows down and eventually hangs up Homey. Some ppl even reboot their Homey every night automatically to solve this. I believe most of the issues were solved after 2.2 (not sure which firmware exactly though)
I don’t have the hue app, but experienced memory leak also. But after upgrading to 2.4.1 it is gone. I am still on 2.4.1.

I’m on 3.1.0. It is much better than 2.x. in terms of stabikity for me. But still, Athom takes care for homey and HUE app. HUE app is probably one of most used and updated and it still has problems. So I cant do nothing but wait :frowning:

I have also issues with the Hue App. The workaround is to restart the the app every 6 hours.
But I can’t understand why the app does not restart automatically if it becomes paused?! Or why the status paused is not available as a trigger?

I presume you all give a the hue a static IP?
When the lease time is expired that was given by the router for hue it could be that a new IP is chosen.

Hi @PetervdK. First of all, thank you very much for thinking along. It doesn’t seem a memory issue. Even 15 minutes after reboot the responsiveness is to cry about. I will however go check insights regularly. Homey is lots of times also very slow in responding when building flows and such. I have good hopes dual core will help for that.

The mesh/z-wave area you point at does seem a likely suspect. If I execute a flow manually, the lights respond almost immediately. Through a button, not so much (even sometimes 30 seconds). I’ll check the z-wave debug-log to see how fast the command is received by Homey classic (first-batch-backer). Over here you can see my mesh-set-up: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1D1viunxH7MZABG0DBQi01qwpRNqOI6nB/view?usp=sharing though I cannot judge if that’s problematic or not. That’s for z-wave.

Then the hue’s. I rearranged the Hue’s in the hub. I got 100+ invalid_id errors on 100+ Hue lights (via their hubs) in Homey. I then decided to delete 130+ Hue devices from Homey (devices through their Philips Hubs, cause I want to keep the Philips firmware updates and fallback in that app). Homey does seem to respond a bit faster. Maybe Homey upates the Hue’s by iterating them and calling status API’s polling based. That could explain some slowness, and Homey being busy so much.

My electronics guy is almost finished hacking the antenna mod in a Homey Pro, so I’m very curious if life will get better from that on. He’s gonna migratie my house room by room. I will post that here, but it might take some time. Having said that, I’m almost on topic again of this thread.

He has almost as little time as me, though. So be patient. On the (cynical) bright side, if my wife leaves me due to a non-working house, I’ll have plenty of time.

I think this questing is much bigger than “being able to migrate to homey pro”.
I cannot believe that we are not able to backup and restore homey at all!

That there isn’t a way to backup and restore homey not only makes me a bit worried. It’s a core feature of any device that you use to control your house, and any device that you’ll loose so much time reconfiguring in case of a failure.

The community have asked for a backup solution for as long as I’ve been part of this community, and the closest things we have seen is a few community driven projects trying to solve this problem.

Athom does not seem very interested in speaking about it, but my best guess is that this, for some reason is really hard to implement, otherwise it would have been here from the start. Right?

Implementing a working backup feature now, should make extra sense since the release of homey pro. Should generate a few extra sales to users that already have a homey.
I would be one of the first to jump on one.

Why so concerned now on a thread almost 2 months old,
If you read Homey+ subscription or Homey Cloud Backup - (part of Homey+ subscription)you would know this is now really on the way and just is this what is asked. Only not yet officially announced and available.
I guess days or maybe a couple af weeks max,

2 Likes

146/5000

I hope you are right Dijker, that we will soon be offered a solution for backup.
We have been waiting for this long enough, and much more than 2 months.

I have not read these threads, and it makes me very happy to know that this is on the way after all these years,

Maybe the next time read first, complain later?

Fair point, did a search and didn’t look hard enough, Homey Cloud Backup - (part of Homey+ subscription) is the 6th result when searching for backup, and the 5th searching for “migrate to home pro” where this is the first thread. The rest of the threads are, like this one, a Wailing Wall of the missing feature

Now everyone else finding this post first when searching will also find the solution.

2 Likes